Skip to main content

Participatory Budgeting: What Do Citizens Want?


Since its birth in Porto Alegre, participatory budgeting, that is, the process through which citizens are actively involved in allocating a portion of budgetary resources, has attracted increased attention worldwide. It has been heralded as a possible answer to the current public finances crisis, the shortfall in public administration legitimacy, the loss of trust in representative democracies, and the need to foster local development and growth.
But under which conditions can participatory budgeting work? What do citizens want when participating in budgeting decisions?
According to a recent review of public budgeting, more needs to be uncovered and understood about participatory budgeting, and what citizens expect. The process remains largely unexplored.
We recently investigated how Italian citizens perceive participatory budgeting and the way in which it is implemented. We found four typologies of citizens being involved in participatory budgeting. First is the supporter in theory, but doubtful in practice, who think that participatory budgeting has significant potential for ensuring stronger involvement of citizens and collaboration among stakeholders, but point to the risks that the participatory process may become controlled by elites.
Second are the citizens who appear to be particularly worried about the trade-off between consensus and creativity, as they are see the risk of politicization of participatory budgeting and that the need for consensus may even “crowd-out” energies devoted to creating and designing projects. Third are the supporters of a community approach, who recognize the importance of  balance between more targeted and collective needs in budgeting decisions, and pervasive information sharing and transparency. The fourth group are those who are aware of citizens’ importance and strongly focusing on the role of citizens as enablers and recipients of participatory budgeting with a central role in differentiating resource allocation amongst different actors and types of projects.
All in all, it appears that the successful implementation of participatory budgeting depends on four central factors: responsiveness, representation, interaction, and inclusiveness.
Responsiveness concerns continuous attention to citizens’ needs and the capacity to use the participatory budgeting process to identify and respond not only to parochial needs but also to the collective needs. The development of a broader awareness and better understanding of the collective needs is not easy and requires time.
Representation refers to the extent to which different interests, views, and power positions have voice in the process and requires that decisions on how to spend public money are made mainly through open debates. This ensures that voice and views are expressed, and reduces conflict, while selecting and compromising on possible solutions.
Interaction refers to establishing a continuous two-way channel of communication between public administrators and citizens that is adjusted over time.
Finally, inclusiveness is needed for achieving democracy and for guaranteeing a more equal allocation of resources. The municipality is responsible for removing the barriers to citizens participation by making the process more open, facilitating the collection of information from the various stakeholders (e.g., associations, specific interest groups, citizens), increasing the transparency of the process at each stage and ensuring broader access in terms, for example, of linguistic mediation and physical access.

by Ileana Steccolini, Member, CIPFA Faculty Board, Professor of Accounting and Finance & Research Director, Newcastle University London and Maria Francesca Sicilia, Professor of Accounting and Finance & Research Director, Newcastle University London | November 20, 2017 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

CENTRAL BANK OF NIGERIA (CBN) Deputy Gov Disowns Fake e-mail Address.

Disclaimer CBN Deputy Gov Disowns Fake e-mail Address CBN Deputy Gov Disowns Fake e-mail Address The attention of the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) has been drawn to the activities of fraudsters impersonating some principal officers of the Bank in an attempt to defraud unsuspecting members of the public. Of particular concern to the Bank is the recent message sent from an e-mail purportedly belonging to the Deputy Governor, Corporate Services, Mr. Edward Lametek Adamu, transacting a phony business deal. We wish to inform all members of the public, particularly members of the social media community that officials of the CBN do not communicate with emails outside the @cbn.gov.ng domain. No principal officer of the Bank will transact business or ask you to transact business with any other platform outside those ending with @cbn.gov.ng. The CBN also wishes to warn the public that it will not be liable for any financial transaction which may have transpired between people and sca...
Post a Comment
Explore more »

Outreach event on the principles of disclosure discussion paper in Hong Kong

On 5 September 2017, the Hong Kong Institute of CPAs and the IASB will host a joint outreach event in Hong Kong on the IASB dis­cus­sion paper DP/2017/1 'Dis­clo­sure Ini­tia­tive — Prin­ci­ples of Dis­clo­sure'. The event will cover main elements of the  dis­cus­sion paper , including: “what con­sti­tutes effective com­mu­ni­ca­tion in the financial reports;” “what con­sti­tutes fair pre­sen­ta­tion of per­for­mance measures such as EBITDA;” “when, where and how financial in­for­ma­tion should be disclosed.” For more in­for­ma­tion, see the  press release  on the IASB’s website.
Post a Comment
Explore more »

New—and Important—Role for Professional Accountants in Assessing Human Rights Risk

  When law firms are hiring specialists focusing on human rights as advisors to business, business at large must take note. Over the last few months, at a range of events, I have heard first hand from such new professional legal associates of the importance of horizon scanning and the how the landscape is changing in regard to corporate responsibility. Human rights and business is an emerging area that is set to accelerate and, as no any business can rest assured without further investigation that their full supply chain is “clean”, assessing and addressing potential risk in this area is clearly also a role for the professional accountant . In recent years, the operating environment for business has changed irreversibly. Companies will be increasingly called to account to show what they have done to prevent disasters like the 2013 Rana Plaza garment factory collapse in Bangladesh that cost over a thousand lives. It is not only the clothing industry that is affected by human rig...
Post a Comment
Explore more »